My Sugar Pie in Zionsville, IN
Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie New Orleans 2021 - Slice of pie with fresh whipped cream — illustrative photo
Display case in a Chinese bakery — illustrative photo
Cake display cases with cakes and pastries in Brastads Bageri 4 — illustrative photo

My Sugar Pie

Your guide to this pie shop on 40 E Pine St, Zionsville — hours, map, menu and directions.

Pie shop
Get directions (317) 733-8717 See the menu

Opening hours

 
Eastern Time
Opening hours have not been published for this bakery yet. Call (317) 733-8717 to check today's hours. Know the hours? Send them to us.
Tap for directions

40 E Pine St, Zionsville, IN 46077

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps
Address40 E Pine St, Zionsville, IN 46077
Phone(317) 733-8717
StylePie shop
CountyBoone County
Time zoneEastern Time

About My Sugar Pie

You will find My Sugar Pie at 40 E Pine St in Zionsville, right in the middle of Zionsville.

Zionsville has 6 places on our map that bake or sell fresh pastry, and this is one of them, roughly one for every 5,527 residents. The closest neighbour on our map is Gables Bagels, less than 0.1 mi away.

We have not been able to confirm a full weekly schedule for My Sugar Pie yet, so calling ahead at (317) 733-8717 is the safest bet. Bakeries often sell out of popular items by early afternoon.

What to order

Typical items at a pie shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Fruit pies

  • Blackberry cobbler pieWild-style blackberries under a tender biscuit-like topping, rustic and juicy with a slight seedy crunch.
  • Classic apple pieDouble-crust pie with tart and sweet apples, cinnamon and nutmeg under a flaky, sugar-sprinkled top crust.
  • Cherry lattice pieTart red cherries thickened into a glossy filling beneath a woven lattice crust that bakes up crisp and golden.
  • Blueberry pieJuicy blueberries with lemon zest and a hint of cinnamon, bubbling up through vents in the flaky top crust.

Cream & custard pies

  • Key lime pieTart lime custard made with condensed milk and Key lime juice, set in a graham cracker crust.
  • Lemon meringue pieSharp lemon filling capped with a tall, sweet meringue toasted until the peaks turn golden brown.
  • Chocolate cream pieCooked chocolate pudding filling, smooth and dense, chilled in a cookie crumb crust with whipped topping.
  • Butterscotch cream pieBrown sugar and butter custard with a deep caramel flavor, topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream.

Southern & heritage pies

  • Sweet potato pieSmooth, spiced custard of roasted sweet potato, brown sugar and nutmeg; lighter and earthier than pumpkin.
  • Buttermilk chess pieSimple Southern custard of eggs, sugar, butter and buttermilk, baked until the top caramelizes into a thin crust.
  • Hoosier sugar cream pieIndiana's creamy, eggless custard of cream and sugar dusted with nutmeg, sweet and gently set.
  • Shoofly piePennsylvania Dutch molasses pie with a wet, gooey bottom layer and a crumbly spiced topping.

Photos

All photos
My Sugar Pie in Zionsville, IN
My Sugar Pie
Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie New Orleans 2021 - Slice of pie with fresh whipped cream — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo
Display case in a Chinese bakery — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo
Cake display cases with cakes and pastries in Brastads Bageri 4 — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo

Visitor reviews

Write a review
No reviews yet. Been to My Sugar Pie? Your review helps other people decide — be the first to write one.

Questions about My Sugar Pie

What are My Sugar Pie's hours?
We have not verified a weekly schedule for My Sugar Pie yet. Call (317) 733-8717 to confirm before visiting.
Where is My Sugar Pie located?
My Sugar Pie is at 40 E Pine St, Zionsville, IN 46077. Tap the map on this page to open turn-by-turn directions.
What is the phone number for My Sugar Pie?
The listed phone number is (317) 733-8717.
What should I order at My Sugar Pie?
As a pie shop, typical picks include Blackberry cobbler pie, Classic apple pie, Key lime pie, and Lemon meringue pie. See the full menu page for more.
What other bakeries are near My Sugar Pie?
Nearby options include Gables Bagels (less than 0.1 mi), The Baker's House (less than 0.1 mi), and Not As Famous Cookie Company (0.2 mi).

Bakeries near My Sugar Pie

Gables Bagels
Gables Bagels270 S Main St, Zionsville
less than 0.1 mi awayBagel shop
The Baker's House
The Baker's House365 S Main St, Zionsville
less than 0.1 mi awayBakery
Not As Famous Cookie Company
Not As Famous Cookie Company30 E Poplar St, Zionsville
0.2 mi awayCookie shop
Confectioneiress Cupcakes
Confectioneiress Cupcakes80 Brendon Way, Zionsville
0.8 mi awayCupcake shop
Rise'n Roll Bakery - Zionsville
Rise'n Roll Bakery - Zionsville11581 Sylo Xing, Zionsville
0.9 mi awayBakery
Homemade Ice Cream & Bakery Cafe
Homemade Ice Cream & Bakery Cafe10875 N Michigan Rd, Carmel
1.3 mi awayBakery café
Kolache Factory
Kolache Factory10460 N Michigan Rd, Carmel
1.6 mi awayKolache shop
American Society of Baking
American Society of Baking4231 W 96th St, Indianapolis
2.3 mi awayBakery
All bakeries in Zionsville6 bakeries on one map Pie ShopsFind more near you Open right nowBakeries open at this moment near you